5x5 roto keeper. Which side is better? Team A gets: Hanley Ramirez, Andrew McCutchen, Justin Smoak Team B gets: Matt Kemp, Jimmy Rollins, Desmond Jennings
Any difference if Team B gets Troy Tulowitzki instead of Rollins
Last edited by CrimeDog on Sat Mar 20, 2010 10:06 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Since its a keeper, I would be inclined to favor team A. I just done know how many productive years rollins will have. Mcutchen looks like a solid player and han ram obviously, aside from pujols, is the greatest fantasy scorer as he is a ss. I would go with team A.
I would probably not do the deal with Rollins. However if it is Tulo instead of Rollins I think I am pulling that trigger superfast.
To me Rollins has started to ease into the backstretch. The guy has played a ton of baseball the last few years and although I still think he will be very productive, in a keeper, his value is lessened. Tulo is just the opposite, a young sutd who is hitting his stride. You are essentially getting two legitimate 1st round picks in Kemp and Tulo if you could swing it.
Take Kimbo's advice to the bank. No if it's Rollins, yes if it's Tulo. And don't be afraid to ask for something else, too. Please remember that McCutcheon's power last year came virtually in one game; he's not Kemp.
Team A is better, unless you include Tulo, then Team B gets the benefit. I'm in the minority on Tulo that I think he is VERY close to Ramirez, jsut doesn't have the track record. Look at his season last year if you take out the first month and a half - he's a stud.
Cafe Home
Fantasy Football
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by CrimeDog » Sat Mar 20, 2010 9:53 pm 
