Please help with this 8 player trade (WHIR!!!!!!!!!)

[reblaze369]

He is offering: Halladay, Hamels, Victorino and kurt suzuki
He wants: Vmart, Hanson, sizemore and wandy

Is this a fair trade, would u take it? (whir!)

Im in a cbs 10 team h2h points league/non keeper
This is my team

Martinez, Victor C
Morales, Kendry 1B
Lopez, Jose 2B
Wright, David 3B
Ramirez, Hanley SS
Abreu, Bobby RF
Choo, Shin-Soo RF
Sizemore, Grady CF
Lee, Derrek 1B

Active Pitchers

Beckett, Josh SP
Floyd, Gavin SP
Hanson, Tommy SP
Nolasco, Ricky SP
Rodriguez, Wandy SP
Bailey, Andrew RP
Soriano, Rafael RP

Reserve Pitchers
De La Rosa, Jorge SP
Harang, Aaron SP
Marcum, Shaun SP
Sanchez, Jonathan O. SP
Sheets, Ben SP

[brakeyawself]

I would do the trade. It would greatly improve your pitching IMO. Sizemore is a bit overrated. Victorino should do nice in your lineup.

Please see mine:

viewtopic.php?t=404026

[CrimeDog]

Personally I believe Hanson's numbers won't be very far off from Halladay. I also like Wandy quite a bit and believe he may actually better Hamels numbers, especially in K's. Philly is better than the other 2 teams, but wins are hard to project. I think Sizemore is due for a bouncback and will easily outproduce Victorino. V-Mart will outproduce Suzuki pretty easily as well. I would stay put if I were you.

[sha]

i like this offer for you. gives you sure fire stud on the mound. i agree that sizemore may be overrated and vicotrino could put up comparable numbers. i also like hamels as a huge bounce back candidate. i say do it.
see mine?


viewtopic.php?t=404038

[reblaze369]

thanks...any other ideas??

[BUCCOFAN]

Id stand pat also. Everyone is on the Halladay bandwagon (tearing apart the NL etc) that might be so, but all the rest of the players involved in this deal, lean back to you.

Halladay vs Hanson = Doc
Suzuki vs V.Mart = V.Mart
Sizemore vs Victorino = Grady by a land slide (big bounce back)
Hamels vs Wandy = pretty even

This isn't the worse deal I have seen, (pretty even) But I would just stand pat since the offense switching sides here, wouldn't favour you.

When in doubt go with the BATS!!!

Thanks

[reblaze369]

Would any1 else take the trade? I guess it all depedns on how u feel sizemore will do.