keep 4 corner infielders???

[pmccurry]

Is it crazy for me to keep Miguel Cabrera, Evan Longoria, Ryan Zimmerman AND Mark Reynolds in my keeper league? We are allowed to keep up to 5, but I dont really know who else to pick. My other options are to trade Zimmerman for a 9th round pick or keep one of the following instead or in addition to: Jon Lester, Jose Reyes, Nelson Cruz or Nick Markakis. Please help!

[smoovethug]

If you can fit these guys at CI/IF and UTIL then no it's not crazy, it'll just give you less flexibility but it's hard to argue with that core. If not, then I'd think about keeping Reyes over Zimmerman, but not trading him for a 9th rndr.

[raiders_umpire]

I would keep Reyes and Lester over Reynolds.

[Johnny Tuttle]

Keep your 4 CI listed and Reyes.

Lester's awesome, but Reynolds might have been #2 overall last year, and certainly, he was in the mix with Pujols/Mauer/Hanley as the creme-de-la-creme. No way I pass on that even for a stellar SP.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=403960