Which is a better waiver guy for my bench: Vlad or Pierre?

[waltb87]

I have Juan Pierre right now, and someone just dropped Vlad today so i am putting waiver claims on him, and I picked up Pierre the night of the draft because I thought he would give me some speed, but from what I am hearing he won't be stealing that much, so should I keep Juan Pierre or get Vlad, in other words, who would be the better guy to keep on my roster for my bench?

Here is my roster:
Team A - yahoo! 12 team h2h league...standard stats
c - jorge posada
1b - Mark Teixieria
2b - dan uggla
3b - Kevin Yokilis
ss - Jason Bartlett
of - Ryan Braun, Johnny Damon, Carlos Beltran
util - Josh Hamilton, Alfonso Soriano
bn - Juan Pierre, Casey McGee, Magglio Ordonez

sp - Ryan Dempster, Erik Bedard, Cole Hamels, kevin correia, Edwin Jackson, Shaun Marcum, Dice - K( i know my pitching sucks)
rp -Ryan Franklin, Brad Lidge, Chad Qualls

[smoovethug]

I'd rather drop Maggs for Vlad, but if it's between just these two I'm keeping Pierre as you could use the speed.

[Johnny Tuttle]

McGahee or Maggs should go instead.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=403960

[Philliebuster]

Gezuz, who ever thought we'd ever have to ask this question? HA...but it is legit. I'd also look to drop Mcgehee for Vlad.

[Pogotheostrich]

Another vote to drop MaGahee instead. You could really use Pierre's SB.