Who’s the best catcher in the history of NY baseball?

[madmikey]

Anyone else hear about the new baseball show called The Lineup on the MSG network, where a panel with people like Hall of Fame Mets catcher Gary Carter and former Yankee bullpen ace Sparky Lyle will determine the best baseball players in the history of NY? Sounds pretty cool and it looks like they will be talking about different positions every week and this week they are debating the best NY catchers.

I just found this game where you can try to match your picks with the panels: www.msg.com/lineup/ If you play, you can win some autographed stuff. And When you watch the first show (Tues. 23rd at 10:30pm) you'll know if your picks match the panel's.


These were my picks for best catcher

Yogi Berra
Mike Piazza
Elston Howard
Jorge Posada
Bill Dickey


What do you guys think?? Who did you guys pick?

[mariposaskyman]

I think your list is pretty darn good. I think Berra, Dickey, Posada, Munson, Piazza. I know I have Piazza a bit lower than you do, but he didn't play that many seasons, eight, so the others might be higher because of that.