Who to play? Kearns, EMartinez, Phelps, Drew, Encarnacion

[Egregious]

I need to pick two of these to fill out my OF and Util spots. Which two should I play and why? At the moment I'm leaning towards Encarnacion and Kearns.

Here's my full roster:
12 team, 5x5 keeper league
My team:
C Posada
1B Derek Lee
2B Giles, Marcus
3B Rolen, Scott
SS Garciaparra, Nomar
OF G. Anderson, J. Damon, J.D. Drew
Util Josh Phelps
Bench Encarnacion, E Martinez, Kearns

SP: Vazquez, M. Morris, Sabathia, B. Myers, Eaton, Kip Wells
RP: Dotel, Nathan, Lidge, R. Soriano, Ayala

[Pedantic]

I'd play Kearns. I don't think you need to play Encarnacion or Edgar unless Drew gets hurt.

[Egregious]

Even with Encarnacion's steals, you'd play Drew and Kearns over him? Are Encarnacion's steals expected to drop a whole lot with his move to LA?

[hooligan1]

I prefer Kearns and Phelps at those spots, if it's my team. I think the steals are going to be down for Juan E., perhaps by as much as half....He really doesn't bring a lot of power......