Kemp+Longoria for Kinsler+Aramis+Gallardo

[ImStupid]

Standard 5x5 roto scoring keeper league.

Which side of that deal would you rather have?

[Alexs]

kemp/longoria....

[hstlives]

in a keeper without knowing rosters or anything like that Kemp/Longoria, by quite a bit. Kinsler is solid at 2B, but is turning in the the Chipper Jones of the AL with injuries. Gallardo also solid, but a high BB/9 rate will keep him from the top tier of pitchers. Aramis is getting up in age (especially compared to Longoria) and losing value in a keeper league

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=403575

[Element]

in a keeper without knowing rosters or anything like that Kemp/Longoria, by quite a bit. Kinsler is solid at 2B, but is turning in the the Chipper Jones of the AL with injuries. Gallardo also solid, but a high BB/9 rate will keep him from the top tier of pitchers. Aramis is getting up in age (especially compared to Longoria) and losing value in a keeper league

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=403575

I think that you're wrong about Gallardo. He hit a wall after a large workload increase following his 2008 knee injury. He's going to be an excellent starter.

With that said, Kemp and Longo are the best two players in the deal. I want that side.

[B-Chad]

I'd rather have the better keepers in this deal, and take the Kemp/Longoria side. In a re-draft it's a lot closer, but in this case, I don't think it's all that close, and I own Kinsler in a keeper and love Gallardo, so this is relatively unbiased.