For your first one, I'd definitely go Pedroia first. Then Phillips, Cano, and Roberts (although I would take Aaron Hill over Roberts).
For your second one, I'd go Greinke, CC, Verlander, Haren, and Lester.
I would fill up your most important spots first. If Pedroia or Phillips are there, take one of them. If neither of them are there, I'd get a pitcher, either Greinke, CC, or Verlander. If none of them are there, then Cano. If you're gonna choose between Verlander and Lester, definitely go with Verlander.
Please answer mine: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=403596&p=3218423#p3218423