Please help me pick 1 of 3 keepers

[Slambo]

Pick one of:

Felix Hernandez
Adam Dunn
Justin Upton

Redraft league with 5 keepers.

Points scoring:
Hitters: 1B=1, 2B=2, 3B=3, HR=4, R=1, RBI=1, BB=1
Pitchers: IP=2, W=10, CG=5, SV=10, SO=1, H=-0.5, BB=-0.5, ER=-1

This scoring makes players like Dunn more valuable than he would be in a 5X5 since the HR scores big, there is no AVG, and BB score points so don't write him off right away. As I see it:

Hernandez: + young & awesome, - a pitcher (don't like to keep them)
Adam Dunn: + consistent & reliable, - no upside & outfielder (lots of good ones)
Justin Upton: + young and big potential, - unproven & outfielder, possible injury risk

Please help!

[xtreme99]

Pick one of:

Felix Hernandez
Adam Dunn
Justin Upton

Please help!

If you throw king Felix back into a keeper pot he will be gone by round 1. He is a top 3 stud, Dunn and Upton are great but not top 3 great

[Slambo]

Just for reference last year they scored:

Hernandez: 692
Dunn: 591
Upton: 525

[xtreme99]

Just for reference last year they scored:

Hernandez: 692
Dunn: 591
Upton: 525

Doesn't change anything....Felix

[thejusman1]

In a neutral scoring set-up, I'd choose Upton here without a doubt. Given this scoring setup, however, it would be hard not to keep Felix if he really did outscore Dunn by 100 points and Upton by 160+ points. So, Felix for this league's scoring.

[raiders_umpire]

I would hate to throw Upton or Felix back. Who are your other 4 keepers?

[Grounded Polo]

I'd keep Felix with those settings but really, letting go of J-Up in a keeper is absurd to me, you can't have like Pujols, Braun, Kemp, and Hanley for the other 4 keepers, right?