Roberts or Figgins

[cnasty]

I need a 3B and a 2B so position does not matter here. Clearly Roberts originally was the favorite here before we have heard of this injury. I am very scared that this Roberts thing will have him in and out of the line up all year long. Which guy do you prefer and why?

[jake_twothousandfive]

I'll say Roberts in spite of the injury. I think leaving LAA significantly hurts Figgins' value. He'll likely run less and score fewer runs in a less potent offense. And he's no sure thing to stay healthy either.

[trevizzle]

the question really doesn't make sense. roberts and figgi play totally different positions. and we need more information. post your league format and your entire roster.

[cnasty]

I said i need both so dont get wat position matters but its a points cbs league. 3 year keeper league, this is our 2nd year and we keep 8 players. I got lucky with some of my picks last year as tulo grienke and j upton are all valued way higher this year than last year. Scoring system is normal set up points for runs rbis & walks.. 2 for steals ... 1 for each total base on a hit and lose a half of a point for a k. This is my roster, and from wat u see I will not keep roberts or figgins next year. Also 9 3b are kept and 7 2b....

C-Wieters
1B-Fielder
2B-
SS-Tulo
3B-
Of-Braun
Of-J.Upton
Of-
Util-Morneau
Util-
Sp-Lincecum
Sp-Grienke