Please help w TRADE (WHIR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)

[reblaze369]

He is offering granderson, reynolds and victorino for my wright and bay
what do u think??? (WHIR!!!)

Im in a 10 team h2h non keeper league

My Team
Molina, Bengie C
Pujols, Albert 1B
Hill, Aaron 2B
Wright, David 3B
Rollins, Jimmy SS
Abreu, Bobby RF
Bay, Jason LF
Kemp, Matt CF
Ortiz, David DH

Active Pitchers
Billingsley, Chad SP
Burnett, A.J. SP
Floyd, Gavin SP
Jurrjens, Jair SP
Weaver, Jered SP
Fuentes, Brian RP
Rivera, Mariano RP

Reserve Pitchers
Lilly, Ted SP
Niemann, Jeff SP
Pettitte, Andy SP
Santana, Ervin SP
Marmol, Carlos RP

[Wadderboiz]

I'd say pull the trigger on that deal. You're going to take a little hit in average but you have plenty of high average guys in your lineup and I don't think Citi Field is going to kill Wright/Bay's power #'s.

[reblaze369]

Thanks....this is a h2h points based league...i forgot to mention. Any other opinions?

[Kimbos Beard]

I am not making that trade at all....I don't see how giving up Wright and Bay is going to make your team any better. You are giving up the best player in the deal for some mid to later round guys in a 10 team league.

Your offense looks fine If I were you and were looking to make a deal I would be looking to improve pitching.

[bazzy_51]

I like 4 out of the 5 players named. The one player I don't like and don't have as much confidence in to repeat last year, as others may have, is Reynolds. Mark is the dealbreaker for me for the simple fact that I'm not sure that getting his average, ontop of Grandy's average will be able to be made up with the power numbers they MAY generate.

No way Wright has as bad of a power year this year as he did last, and even if he does his average and SB make up for the loss of HR. IMO you have a lock at the hot corner with Wright and replacing him with Reynolds is a huge question mark. I like your OF the way it sits with all three having above average speed, good average numbers and Kemp is the complete package with power/speed/average. I see Bay dipping a bit compared to last years power numbers, but only half the games are played at Citi, so I don't think it will hurt him THAT much. I still like Bay in Citi more then Grandy in NY.

I personally would stick with what you have, heck the package of Pujols, Wright, Rollins, Kemp, Bay and if Hill can even come close to last years numbers, your going to be hard to beat. I would actually be looking harder at your arms then your bats. Looking at it, I think, well hope, that Bills has a bounce back year, but if he doesn't your looking at Burnett being your #1 and with his ratios thats going to hurt. After Bills and AJ your looking kind of iffy at the back half of your rotation, Floyd should be solid, but again I don't see Jair replicating last years ERA and thats where his value is at, Jered Weaver is solid but has also had his woes and also the new added pressure of being the Angels new #1. Lilly is hit and miss and with a career 4.25 ERA he can miss big at times, Pettitte will be lucky to hit 140 Ks and is on the way wrong side of 4 ERA wise and his 1.40 hovering WHIP the past few years will ultimatley makes him a spot starter. Santana has had one big year sandwiched inbetween 2 aweful ones, and still has question marks about a. injury and b. confidence. Niemann may be your darkhorse, kid as stuff that is compareable to SP1 status, just has to be given a good chance.

Overall your squad is worthy, but again I would stress looking into arms, rather then bats.

help me out...

viewtopic.php?t=403057