Rollins/Weaver for Kemp deal?

[gopirates!]

Hey guys

Good to be back in season. Anyway, We had our draft about a week ago, and I've already got a trade offer. It is as follows:

I get: Matt Kemp
He gets: Jimmy Rollins/Jered Weaver

Here's my current roster:

C Yadier Molina
1B Billy Butler
2B Chase Utley
3B Mark Reynolds
SS Jimmy Rollins
OF Jacoby Ellsbury
OF Jayson Werth
OF Adam Dunn
Utility Nick Johnson/Johnny Damon/Corey Hart

SP Yovani Gallardo
SP John Lackey
SP Jered Weaver
RP Francisco Cordero
RP Frank Francisco
P Matt Capps
P Matt Lindstrom
Bench John Danks
Bench Gavin Floyd
Bench Kevin Slowey
Bench Derek Lowe
Bench Kyle Lohse

I tend to think my offense is pretty well-rounded, and my pitching is pretty deep. However, getting Kemp would give my outfield a huge boost. At the same time, however, shortstop is a pretty thin position, which causes me to be hesitant to give up Rollins. And my pitching would take a slight hit. All in all, do you guys think I should do this? Leave a link I'll help in return fo sho

[Seanyfever]

Value seems about right, but I need to know how you fill SS before jumping on this.

Lend a hand here
viewtopic.php?t=402740

[Rance Mulliniks]

Getting Kemp is a great move. Is there anyone on the waiver that you could plug in at SS? If there's a good enough option, I'd take this for sure. You could also try to move a depth OF (Damon) for a SS.

[BALCO All-Stars]

Do this on value alone.

Maybe turn around and offer Ellsbury/+ for Tulo or something like that.

[Elsy]

Getting Kemp is a great move. Is there anyone on the waiver that you could plug in at SS? If there's a good enough option, I'd take this for sure. You could also try to move a depth OF (Damon) for a SS.

Agreed

[gopirates!]

In respoonse to you guys, SS is pretty thin. There are players like furcal, hardy, aybar on the waiver wire. Would these gguys be sufficient to fill in?

[Elsy]

In respoonse to you guys, SS is pretty thin. There are players like furcal, hardy, aybar on the waiver wire. Would these gguys be sufficient to fill in?

Aybar
Furcal
Hardy

In that order and they are sufficient enough

[j24jags]

Do it then you have plenty of time to swing a deal for a SS. Your staff can definitely survive without Weaver

[gopirates!]

any other thoughts? lovin the advice so far...keep it comin!

[The Artful Dodger]

Even though you don't have SS cover, I'd go with Kemp. I'd try to swing one of Ellsbury/Werth/Dunn in a deal for a SS.