Looking for Trading advice

[OriolesMagic]

First off here is my team quickly
C - Wieters
1B - Morales
2B - Cano
3B - Sandoval
SS - Bartlett
OF - Lind
OF - Victorino
OF - Reimold
UTIL - Ian Stewart, Nate McLouth
Bench - Bruce, Juan Rivera, Tejada
SP - Lincecum, Halladay, Josh Johnson, Edwin Jackson, De La Rosa, Brian Matusz
RP - Cordero, Gonzalez
Bench - Price, Penny
I have 2 different offers at the moment.
Offer 1) My Halladay, Bartlett, Jackson for his Tulowitzki
Offer 2) My Sandoval, Johnson for his Miguel Cabrera, Jorge Cantu

I'm thinking on both of these but really thinking hard about the 2nd offer as I can put Morales at UTIL, Cantu at 3B, Cabrera at 1B, and I still have Lincecum and Halladay to hold down the pitching staff. Please give me any thoughts you have on this, thanks!