Who wins this deal?

[richjonsess]

H2H redraft league 14 teamer, standarad 5x5

Pedroia
Slowey
Snider (TOR)

for

Cain
Mcclouth
F.Francisco (TEX)

thanks, post your links WHIR

[Grounded Polo]

The Cano side, Slowey/Snider are really shakey options, McLouth and Francisco are safer bets to produce. Cano isn't a huge downgrade from Pedroia.

[fcnick]

Haha, someone misread the trade. I'd rather have the Cain side. Snider/Slowey could have big seasons however.

[Y`s Guy]

Since it's H2H and going by just the players you mentioned I'll take the Cain, McLouth, Francisco because it gives you all stats across the board in one swoop.

I love Snider this year and Slowey is so underrated...but in roto. Dustin may be the best player in the deal.

[richjonsess]

ok guys I've tweaked the deal a bit

2 options now are

Cain
Francisco
Mcclouth

for

Pedroia
Slowey
Wade Davis


or

Cain
Francisco
Mcclouth
Rasmus


for

Pedroia
Slowey
Wade Davis
Sean Rodriguez


are either of these any better? does the side getting pedroia win any of these deals in your opinions? thanks WHIR of course