Good Trade or Bad Trade?

[rasto21585]

I was offered a-rod and bobby abreu for morneau and carlos lee and was wondering if this is an offer I should accept. Also I could target miguel cabreral instead of a rod in this trade. What ya guys think?

20 Team Yahoo H2H Dynasty League

my team
c russel martin
1b justin morneau
2b akinori iwamura
3b pablo sandoval
ss ryan theriot
if chase headley
lf carlos lee
cf alex rios
rf ryan ludwick
of colby rasmus
util fukodome
bn xavier nady
bn dayan viciedo
bn alex avila

sp jon lester
sp wandy rodriguez
sp jon danks
sp jair jurrjens
rp george sherrill
rp rafael soriano
rp scott elbert
rp dustin nippert
p ryan rowland smith
p jeremie guthrie
phiroki kuroda
bn geo gonzalez
bn carlos carrasco

[Kimbos Beard]

I would do this trade in a heart beat. You are getting a top 4 pick in A-Rod and you are only given up Lee and Morneau two guys who even in a 20 team league are probably 2nd round and 3rd round material.

Hurry and pull the trigger.

[Kimbos Beard]

I would do this trade in a heart beat. You are getting a top 4 pick in A-Rod and you are only given up Lee and Morneau two guys who even in a 20 team league are probably 2nd round and 3rd round material.

Plus he is throwing in Abreu!

Hurry and pull the trigger.

[onitapgr]

In my opinion, I would try for MCab over ARod in your case, you already have a solid, young 3b in Sandoval and you won't have an eligible 1b next year if you trade morneau......BUT.....arod might be worth it, too

I would also take Abreu over Lee because they are almost the same age, Abreu is on a better team, gets on base more, and has more speed.

Could use your opinion here: viewtopic.php?t=402586

[raiders_umpire]

I would jump all over ARod in this deal.

[fcnick]

Since this is a dynasty league, you have to consider age. MCab will be better for a lot longer than ARod. Plus, like was said before you won't really have a solid 1B without Morneau.

[rasto21585]

Good point guys. So looks like I will be trading for mcab and abreu. So what other moves do you guys think I should make?

[fcnick]

If there's anything you can do to upgrade your current 2B/SS situation, go for it.

[rasto21585]

There is a guy in my league that has expressed some interest in jon lester. I am thinking of doing a trade where I send lester, headley and avila for heyward, wade davis and alcides escobar. How does that sound?

[thejusman1]

There is a guy in my league that has expressed some interest in jon lester. I am thinking of doing a trade where I send lester, headley and avila for heyward, wade davis and alcides escobar. How does that sound?

Don't do this, but do the Arod or Mcab trade quickly.