James Shields for Josh Hamilton

[ChicksDigTheLongBall]

12-team, H2H Keeper League (8 keepers)
Start: C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, 3 OF, 3 Util, 7 P's, 6 bench & 5 minor league prospects
Hittings Points: Single (1pt), Double (2), Triple (3), HR (4), RBI (1), R (1) SB (2), CS (-1), K (-1), BB (1)
Pitching Points: IP (2pts), K (1), BB (-1), W (10), SV (10), L (-10) CG (10), SO (10)

I am being offered his Josh Hamilton for my James Shields, should I pull the trigger?
Also, who would you consider to round out the 8 keepers I need?

My Keepers Right Now:
Miggy Cabrera
Ryan Howard
Pablo Sandoval
Zach Greinke
Jake Peavy
Tommy Hanson

Considering:
Yunel Escobar
Manny Ramirez
Adam Dunn
Vlad Guererro
Alfonso Soriano
James Shields

I also have Yonder Alonso, Neftali Feliz & Wade Davis as minor league keepers that don't count towards the 8.

Thanks for the help!!!

[Pogotheostrich]

I'd make the deal for Hamilton and keep him and Dunn.

[thejusman1]

I'd make the deal for Hamilton and keep him and Dunn.

x2. I'd also try and move MCab or Howard for another stud bat who wasn't a 1B. With Dunn, MCab, and Howard you'll have a lot of 1B power.