First set of keepers

[JoeMoney19]

Quick additional question:

Team is in the same shape as above and I've received an interesting offer:

I give:
Carlos Quentin
Ubaldo Jimenez
10th round pick

I get:
Adam Lind
14th round pick

In doing this, I would effectively also net my 8th round pick (91st overall) by narrowing my keeper list to 7.

At the same time, Quentin's 2008 stats were fairly similar to Lind's 2009.


Is this too much to give up for Lind?


I'll repost my team for reference since this question is on a new page.

First offseason of a keeper league; H2H 12-team league with standard categories:
Hitting - R HR RBI K SB AVG OPS
Pitching - K W L SV ERA WHIP K/9

The way it's set up is that you sacrifice a draft pick for each keeper (i.e., if I keep 6 players I miss the first 6 rounds of the draft)

Right now my keepers are:

C - AJ Pierzynski
1B - Miguel Cabrera
2B - Chase Utley
3B - David Wright
SS - Stephen Drew
LF - Carlos Quentin
CF - Matt Kemp
RF - [ ]
UT - Grady Sizemore
UT - Adam LaRoche
B - Paul Konerko
B - Lastings Milledge

SP - Tommy Hanson
SP - Ubaldo Jimenez
SP - Scott Baker
RP - Rafael Soriano
RP - Carlos Marmol
P - Gavin Floyd
B - Ervin Santana


Thanks!

[JoeMoney19]

Please help! I need to decide by today to get the trade through before we select our keepers.

[Padres Fan]

Since Quentin is a injury risk he can be had in later rounds, he went in the 16th round in my last draft, plus Ubaldo plays in Colorado and could implode pretty quickly I would wait til later and get him. but would keep hanson and the rest

help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=403017

[JoeMoney19]

Can anybody comment on the trade above?

Thanks!