Which Pitcher should I keep

[randyjbeck]

I can keep one of these two as my 8th round pick.

Chris Carpenter or Justin Verlander

I can keep Carpenter this year and next but if I keep Verlander I can keep him this year and the next 3 as 8th round pick.

[Rounders]

I have Verlander slightly over Carpenter in a scratch draft. So, that you have the opportunity to keep him more years puts him even farther above.

viewtopic.php?t=402470

[footballisbetter.com]

I would have like Verlander regardless, but since you can keep him for more years that even makes it easier for me.

[HOOTIE]

I would have like Verlander regardless, but since you can keep him for more years that even makes it easier for me.

[raiders_umpire]

Verlander by a lot

[Rhinochasers]

Another vote for Verlander

[fcnick]

Verlander, easily... this is looking very one sided haha.

[athleticsfan13]

Looks like this has been decided, put another one on the board for J.Verlander

[bronx bombers 06]

another vote for verlander for sure. better pitcher, younger, plus you keep him for extra years, whats not to like