6 player trade

[Padres Fan]

I want to get Alex Gordon and would like more power, will WHIR

I get:
Joey Votto
Alex Gordon
Clayton Richard

For my:
Todd Helton
Josh Hamilton
John Lackey

My Team
C-Joe Mauer
1B-Todd Helton
2B-Brian Roberts
3B-Kevin Kouzmanoff
SS-Yunel Escobar
MI-Jhonny Peralta
CI-Chris Davis
INF-Martin Prado
OF-Grady Sizemore
OF-Andre Ethier
OF-Josh Hamilton
OF-Dexter Fowler
UTIL-David Ortiz
UTIL-Nick Swisher
BN-Delmon Young
BN-Mark DeRosa
BN-Kurt Suzuki
BN-Matt LaPorta

SP-Tim Lincecum
SP-Clayton Kershaw
SP-John Lackey
RP-Jonathan Broxton
RP-Joakim Soria
P-Jered Weaver
P-David Price
P-Brad Penny
P-Chris Young
P-Chris Perez

[Padres Fan]

If it helps here is his team

C-Geovanny Soto
1B-Mark Teixeira
2B-Aaron Hill
3B-Pablo Sandoval
SS-Erick Aybar
MI-Rafael Furcal
CI-Joey Votto
INF-Alex Gordon
OF-Adam Jones
OF-Carlos Quentin
0F-Raul Ibanez
0F-Colby Rasmus
UTIL-Adrian Beltre
UTIL-Nick Johnson
BN-Mat Gamel
BN-Troy Glaus

SP-Roy Halladay
SP-Cole Hamels
SP-Rich Harden
RP-Andrew Bailey
RP-David Aardsma
P-Ted Lilly
P-Carlos Zambrano
P-Derek Lowe
P-Kyle Lohse
P-Clayton Richard
BN-Shaun Marcum
BN-Ryan Rowland-Smith

[Bouillabaisse]

Yeah, I'd make that deal. Go for it.

[springrj]

I think you get the best player with Votto. I don't like Lackey this year, moving to Fenway and the AL East, he may get you wins, but I think his ERA and WHIP will increase, and can Hamilton remain healthy???. Alex Gordon has a broken thumb and could be out for 4 weeks, so that may be something to consider. I actually like Troy Glaus as a sleeper this year, not sure if he has 3B eligibility, but the guy hit 30 HR a year ago.

[Padres Fan]

That's why I offered Hamilton and Lackey, both big name players which I feel concerns for both in regards to home park and durability, also Helton's age does concern me as well

[alee10]

i like votto side of this deal check out my post thanx...

[HOOTIE]

I wouldn't. You lose too much in Hamilton/Lackey.

[fitz0527]

Hopefully you waited long enough to hear Alex Gordon broke his thumb

[MaudDib]

I wouldn't. You lose too much in Hamilton/Lackey.

Hadn't heard this about Gordon which means stay away. Regardless this isn't the deal for you. Gordon is hardly a guy to go after this year and you are overpaying for him and Votto. I like Votto a lot but I don't think Lackey takes that much of a step back for this to benefit you.