Desmond Jennings is the guy that comes to mind for me.
Does your league have a specific rule about what a "rookie" is, ie. zero major league innings, min. at-bats, etc.? If some MLB experience is allowed, I really like Marc Rzepczynski on the pitching side.
"Trying to hit him was like trying to drink coffee with a fork." - Willie Stargell on Sandy Koufax
The Big Train
Major League Manager
Joined: 4 May 2006
Bases this season: 0
Home Cafe: Baseball
Location: At GNC, lookin' for some flaxseed oil...
Justin Smoak (1B for Texas Rangers) is another guy I really like. Chris Davis has had his shot two years now. If he continues to struggle with the K's I can see the Rangers calling this kid up. Scouts rave about him, and compare him to a former Ranger Mark Teixeira.
Heyward Strasburg (whom I dub Stat-Borg if he pans out---patent pending)
In that everyone else, you get Matusz, Jennings, Carlos Santana, Wade Davis, Neftali Feliz, Pedro Alvarez, Smoak, and Madison Bumgarner. My sincere apologies if I'm leaving out a blue chipper who could get promoted this year, but I don't think I am. Maybe Taylor. Jesus is blocked. Castro talk is lunacy. Ackley's not preposterous at all.
Then, you have the graduates of opportunity: -Drew Storen: could be nice sleeper, or he could be Weathers, Motte, Perez, Fields, Perry, and Schlereth (i.e., all of the other college closers supposed to move quick, quick) -Sizemore: Polanco v2.0 -Escobar: If only UZR were a fantasy stat -Borbon: Ellsbury at a steep discount -Stubbs: If Borbon is a poor man's Ells, Stubbs is the living in a box equivalent
For me, I would want the elite of the elite. I would want Hey, Stras, Carlos, Feliz, Matusz, Davis, Jennings, Montero, Alvarez in roughly that order. (I see Jennings as blocked: he is quite good, of course).
You know your league better than I. I can't see Sizemore and his guaranteed spot over a Heyward, but you would know how valuable an out of the gates starter is.