Please help w TRADE (WHIR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)

[reblaze369]

I am offered 2 trades: Trade 1: I get Berkman/Swisher, he gets Johan
Trade 2: I get V-Mart/Swisher, he gets Johan

Im not really fond of swisher. Would you take one of these trades? If not, who would you ask for on his team? (WHIR!!!!!!)

MY 10 team cbs h2h league team

Wieters, Matt C
Fielder, Prince 1B
Phillips, Brandon 2B
Wright, David 3B
Rollins, Jimmy SS
ActiveReserve SS
Abreu, Bobby RF
Ibanez, Raul LF
Suzuki, Ichiro RF
Ortiz, David DH

Active Pitchers
Cain, Matt SP
Hamels, Cole SP
Hanson, Tommy SP
Rodriguez, Wandy SP
Santana, Johan SP
Aardsma, David RP
Hoffman, Trevor RP

Reserve Batters
Jones, Garrett RF

Reserve Pitchers
Arroyo, Bronson SP
Harang, Aaron SP
Sheets, Ben SP
Feliz, Neftali RP

HIS Team

Martinez, Victor C
Pena, Carlos 1B
Kinsler, Ian 2B
Reynolds, Mark 3B
Scutaro, Marco SS
Bruce, Jay RF
Sizemore, Grady CF
Soriano, Alfonso LF
Berkman, Lance 1B

Active Pitchers
Cueto, Johnny SP
Harden, Rich SP
Oswalt, Roy
Peavy, Jake SP
Sabathia, CC SP
Papelbon, Jonathan RP
Rivera, Mariano RP

Reserve Batters
Soto, Geovany C
Swisher, Nick RF
Damon, Johnny LF

Reserve Pitchers
Bailey, Homer SP
Sanchez, Jonathan O. SP

[Grounded Polo]

I take trade 2 and immediately dump Swisher to waivers. V Mart > Johan, Swisher being involved is nonsense.

[oddmanout7]

I would pass. You already have Matt Wieters. While I like VMart, and valuewise that trade may be in your favor, I am not sure moving from the #2 C to the #4 C is worth Johan.

If he really wants Johan, I would ask for Jay Bruce + Pitcher.

Please Help
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=402343

[Kimbos Beard]

I pass on both of those trades. Swisher doesnt have much value in a 10 team league so its essentially V-Mart or Berkman for Santana.

While V-Mart is a stud you have Weiters so you are not desperate to upgrade at Catcher. And to me Santana is being way undervalued this year. I know he is coming off an injury but I wouldn't hesitate to anchor my staff with Santana this year.

[Seanyfever]

Ole! I would also let this one go.

Lend a hand
viewtopic.php?t=402336