2nd Base, 2nd Tier...

[lastingsgriller]

what do you guys think..

Aaron Hill
Ben Zobrist
Dustin Pedroia
Brandon Phillips
Gordon Beckham

(keeper league)

[HOOTIE]

5 Aaron Hill overrated
4 Ben Zobrist
3 Dustin Pedroia a bit overrated
2 Brandon Phillips
1 Gordon Beckham

[lastingsgriller]

5 Aaron Hill overrated
4 Ben Zobrist
3 Dustin Pedroia a bit overrated
2 Brandon Phillips
1 Gordon Beckham

WOW.. bold.. I like hearing new thoughts, but I hope you can elaborate on how a guy with 300 MLB at-bats got ahead a couple established dominators and a guy that hit 35 HR's last year..

[BALCO All-Stars]

what do you guys think..

Dustin Pedroia
Ben Zobrist
Brandon Phillips
Gordon Beckham
Aaron Hill

(keeper league)

Really, you're looking good with any of these options. If it's a keeper league I'd bump Beckham up the list. Pedroia gives a bit of everything with great R totals. I like Zobrist's #'s with his 2B/SS/OF flexibility. Phillips is a solid shot at 25/25.

[GiantsFan14]

I'm just finishing up the 2B tiers article and here's what my 2nd tier looks like:
Pedroia
Phillips
Roberts
Zobrist
Cano

[Pogotheostrich]

Dustin Pedroia
Gordon Beckham
Brandon Phillips
Ben Zobrist
Aaron Hill

[HOOTIE]

5 Aaron Hill overrated
4 Ben Zobrist
3 Dustin Pedroia a bit overrated
2 Brandon Phillips
1 Gordon Beckham

WOW.. bold.. I like hearing new thoughts, but I hope you can elaborate on how a guy with 300 MLB at-bats got ahead a couple established dominators and a guy that hit 35 HR's last year..

You could go Phillips 1, but you said keeper, so Beckham has the most keeper years.
Pedroia is ok, but i prefer Phillips/Beckham more, because of the power.
Hill had a 15% hr/fb ratio last year, way over his norm. He might hit 25, but his contact rate and walk rate didn't improve last year. Beckham might hit a few less hrs, but will hit for better avg., and is the far better athlete.