G. Beckham or B. Phillips?

[ChicksDigTheLongBall]

In a 12 team 6 x 6 roto auction league with $300 salary and a roster that starts a 2B, MI and CI which would you keep at these options:

Gordon Beckham 2010 @ $4, 2011 @ $5 and 2012 @ $6
or
Brandon Phillips 2010 @ $12 and 2011 @ $14

I have kept Phillips for the last 2 seasons, and we have 4 years max to keep a player at a 20% increase.

[yoda87]

Beckham is gonna be better in the long run, and obv cheaper... Go with him and spend your money else where...

Good Luck

[sigriffey]

Beckham is more verasatile (2B and 3B) and will probably be a cleaner bill of health too.

Help me please?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=402036

[teaaker]

I would go with Beckham over Phillips. Maybe this year he won't be better, but I think by 2011 he will be better, and he is obviously cheaper for now and the future.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=402020