Keep Kershaw or Josh Johnson?

[iFantasize]

$1 Clayton Kershaw
or
$3 Josh Johnson

One is an injury risk, the other has control issues. What would you do?

[GiantsFan14]

josh johnson and i don't think it's all that close tbh. i could easily see him putting up a top 10 SP year.

[McStallen]

Yeah keep Josh Johnson- it's not a slight on Kershaw- Johnson is an elite fantasy pitcher, but for some reason no one seems to have noticed

[Rance Mulliniks]

With Kershaw's upside, in a keeper I think it's pretty close. JJ has already proven that he can be an elite SP, so I'd probably go with him. His history of injuries is a bit worrying, but still JJ over Kershaw by a hair.

[drcgull]

JJ and dont look back