hanson, hamels or carpenter WHIR

[alee10]

8 team keeper league i have decided on keeping one SP

tommy hanson

karen (chris) carpenter lol

which one

[alee10]

forgot i have hamels as well so

carpenter
hanson
hamels

are the choices

[alee10]

somebody please help

[nickel14]

i'd probably keep hanson. if you like to take risks though, keep carp--if he's healthy all season he may have better numbers this season...hanson long term though.

[curl]

I'd probably go with Hanson just because I can't bring myself to trust Carpenter to stay healthy and I've never been a Hamels fan.

[HOOTIE]

Hanson
Hamels
Carpenter

[teaaker]

I would def. keep Hanson. He already had a good-great year and he is so young! Lock him up now, and enjoy a long reign of pitching stats barring any injury.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=402020

[iFantasize]

To me, this decision depends on the league. Is this a keeper for only this year? If so, I would go with Carpenter. If you can keep players any longer than 1 year, I would keep Hanson. He's likely to be on another innings limit this year and won't reach 200IP. Carpenter is getting old but will contribute well for the short term. Hammels is a wild card.

Hanson, Carpenter, Hammels. In that order.

Please help with mine. I would like as many opinions as I can get. http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=26&t=401805