Zimmerman and Hansen for Halladay

[smalls2598]

standard 5X5, 5 man keeper (2 batters, 2 pitchers, 1 wild card). 3 year limit on keepers (this is our first year). no penalties on keeping players

I'm already keeping Braun, Utley and Greinke

other players worth considering to keep: Zimmerman, Matt Holliday, Adrian Gonzales, Kershaw and Hansen

And, as the topic states, I have been offered Roy Halladay for Ryan Zimmerman and Hansen

Am I crazy if I don't accept this trade? I mean, i'd have two of the top overall pitchers, and a pretty solid hitting nucleus with Braun, Utley and Holliday. Right? But the other view would be that it would be best to keep a young stud like Zimmerman at a weaker position than to keep two outfielders (albeit, two of the best OF).

Help me settle my thought process here. What would you do?

[Wadderboiz]

I'd say no to the trade, Halladay will be great but Hansen will be great for longer and Zimmerman may be the best 3B in the national league.

[HOOTIE]

Let's look at the 2 options

No trade

Braun
Utley
Greinke
Kershaw
WC Zimmermam

With trade

Braun
Utley
Greinke
Halladay
WC A Gonzalez

I like the trade by a hair.