M-Cab -4- Tulo? WHIR

[BigBlue]

4th Year Keeper League
H2H
5x5 Scoring

Please note, I've made a crap ton of trades which is how I've accumulated the team I have.

C: Martin
1B: Pujols
2B: Kinsler
SS: Y. Escobar
3B: Longoria
OF: Beltran
OF: Ellsbury
OF: Ludwick
Util:
Util:
B:

SP: Lincecum, Sabathia, Verlander, Gallardo, Kazmir
RP: Bailey, B. Wilson, Jenks, F. Francisco


The whole trade is:

Tulo/B. Butler/Ichiro

-4-

M. Cabrera/Beltran/Y.Escobar

What say ye?

[Remotethumb]

es, I would do the trade. I'm a believer in Tulo & Butler seems to have finally caught on. They are both young so in a keeper I like that.

It's hard to give up Cabrera, & Yunel is a little underrated but I would do the trade.

[raiders_umpire]

I believe in Tulo as well, but not enough to trade Mcab for. Keep what you have.

[AquaMan2342]

M-Cab is the closest thing to Pujols. Keep him.

[rolen187]

M-Cab is the closest thing to Pujols. Keep him.

agree...mcab is so consistent, if ichiro was a little younger id say do it but i would stand pat

[Grouperman941]

Tulo and M-Cab are my 2 favorite players.

I would not do this deal. Keep the best player (M-Cab).

[HOOTIE]

M-Cab is the closest thing to Pujols. Keep him.

[bloc8888]

I gotta disagree with the majority, I think you do that trade. Yunel ain't bad, but he's clearly the biggest whole in your hitting. Replacing him with the 2nd best SS, who hits for power + some speed... and you get Butler, who I think will have a break out year this year. Ichiro is getting old as dirt, so I might try and trade him off quickly for value, to someone who is trying to make a run at winning this year (though, with your lineup, I can't imagine who will beat you).
MCab is obviously the bomb, but I think the trade helps to construct a rockstar rounded team. Beltras great, but I think we're seeing him in a decline. Could easily put up 20-20, but is an injury risk.

--------------
Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=401662