Red Sox? Really, Dream?
I like the first option better. I think it awards a team for being more competitive. That is, if you suck and lose all 10 cats, and another team loses 4 of 10 in option A they would be scored as 4-6 and 0-10, in B 0-1 each. While maybe not keeping the teams records closer, option A shows a truer gauge of how good or bad teams are.