trade proposal? should i or shouldnt?

[afdZ24]

ive been offered a trade in my 5x5 roto keeper league.

dan haren
FOR
carlos pena & john lackey

im leaning towards taking it.....would this be foolish? is this a fair trade for sides?
who would be winning this deal?

[Pogotheostrich]

I'd be happy with that deal and Haren.

[Tenacious D-Store]

I'd rather have Haren, unless I was critically desperate for power.

[prguy1979]

I'd rather have Haren, unless I was critically desperate for power.

[oddmanout7]

I would stick with Haren. Lackey moving to the AL east doesn't inspire much confidence. I think he will pick up a few more wins, but his ERA will probably hover around 4.

[Rhinochasers]

Haren also

[ensanimal]

Another Haren vote.

[DividedByZero]

Haren's pretty nasty in a roto league. Lackey is solid, but probably won't top any of his numbers from last year. Pena is great for power, but odds are the average is going to suck again.

If you need power, can make up the average, and mind a slight hit to your pitching, then pull the trigger. Otherwise I'd say you're better off with Haren.

[teaaker]

I like Haren here for sure.

viewtopic.php?t=401421

[Big Herm]

+1 on Haren