Trade Hill and Soriano for Beckett and Alx Ramirez?

[jmcampbe11]

The other team could use another closer and I could use a solid starting pitcher to anchor my staff. Thoughts? Fair trade? Good move for me?

Another idea would be to up the ante to Soria or Hoffman and ask for Haren back (instead of Beckett).

GIVE - A.Hill and R.Soriano

GET - Beckett and Alx. Ramirez

MY TEAM - 10 Team Roto League
C-Ianetta 1b-A.Gonzalez 2b-Zobrist ss-Tulowitzki 3b-Wright CI-Sandoval Util-Heyward
OF-Braun - McCutchen - C.Gonzalez - Reimold - Soriano

SP - Gallardo - Hanson - Garza - E.Jackson - Scherzer - W.Davis
RP - Soria - Hoffman - R.Soriano - Wood - Nunez - Lyon

[birdbrains]

I like Beckett and him having a good year this yr...
I also like Hill....
but i do like that trade...


can you look at my post
thank you
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=401366

[Neboguy]

Nice trade as you have a good stock of closers/potential closers. Soriano is no bet to even save 20 games given his injury history and Joe Maddon's tendency to use matchups Vs LHP/RHP to get saves. Do it !!!

[Rhinochasers]

I like the trade also, closers are a dime a dozen.

[HOOTIE]

YES

[raiders_umpire]

I would take the Beckett side.