Rank These SS's WHIR!

[Prooks25]

12 team 5x5 Roto 1250 IP Limit - Keeper League

Elvis Andrus
Asdrubal Cabrera
Yunel Escobar
Alcides Escobar
Alexei Ramirez
Stephen Drew
Erick Aybar
Miguel Tejada
Everth Cabrera
JJ Hardy
Scott Sizemore

[Prooks25]

bump

[Tenacious D-Store]

It might help if you post your team (or team so far), SS is rather shallow and rankings might change based on the assets of who is already on your team. Elvis if you need speed. I like A-Cab and Yunel for a little bit of everything. Drew has the potential to be the best of the list but you just never quite know what you're gonna get from him.

[colt4523]

Here is how I would rank 1-6

5 Elvis Andrus
4 Asdrubal Cabrera
1 Yunel Escobar
6 Alcides Escobar
3 Alexei Ramirez
2 Stephen Drew

help
viewtopic.php?t=400717&start=10

[AquaMan2342]

Elvis Andrus - 1 ( I am higher on him than most, but he has the speed to steal 50 bases)
Asdrubal Cabrera - 3 (Doesn't hurt you in any categories and will have Sizemore and Choo hitting behind him all year)
Yunel Escobar - 5 (Sort of an enigma...he could prove me wrong here or he could be easily the worst one on this list)
Alcides Escobar - 6 (Andrus-lite who should be the leadoff hitter in Milwaukee)
Alexei Ramirez - 2 (Buy in on him after May and you'll get a good player)
Stephen Drew - 4 (I am just not a big Drew fan, probably more personal preference than anything although Arizona's offense is pretty good this year)

[Big Herm]

Alexei Ramirez - I don't think anyone matches his upside on this list
Yunel Escobar - May break out even further this year, hitting that magical age period
Erick Aybar - I'm probably higher than most on this guy, but he stole a ton of bags in the minors and may hit 10-15 hrs and if he bats leadoff for ANA will score a lot runs
Asdrubal Cabrera - Might make strides this year too, seems like a fairly low downside proposition
Elvis Andrus - I think he'll regress with the bat but may steal 40 bags


Just depends on these guys, I like Cabrera as a cheap steals source, I think Tejada can put up good SS numbers and is value if he falls deep enough. Drew's got some upside, but I wouldn't set my expectations too high.
Everth Cabrera
Miguel Tejada
Stephen Drew
Alcides Escobar
JJ Hardy
Scott Sizemore

[HOOTIE]

6 Elvis Andrus could steal 40, bats 9th
8 Asdrubal Cabrera
7 Yunel Escobar solid
5 Alcides Escobar better hitter then Andrus
2 Alexei Ramirez 2nd most upside
1 Stephen Drew most upside imo
10 Erick Aybar
3 Miguel Tejada old, but batting 4th
4 Everth Cabrera should steal 35+, 50 someday, bats leadoff
9 JJ Hardy could be the bargain if he regains power stroke
10 Scott Sizemore could go 15/15

[AquaMan2342]

Batting 9th in Texas isn't necessarily a bad thing.

[HOOTIE]

Batting 9th in Texas isn't necessarily a bad thing.

It cuts into your abs. Each spot in order is 18 abs, so 1st or 9th is a bit of a difference.

[Big Herm]

Batting behind Salty and Davis probably won't get you many RBI opportunities and batting in front of Borbon put you two away from Mike Young with uncertainty in between. I am a big Rangers fan, but doubt I will end up with Andrus or Borbon because I think they will go too high for their relative worth.