Trade Help WHIR

[MaudDib]

I am in a 12 team points league where we keep 25 players. I just got offered

Victorino, McCutchen and Zobrist
for
Either, Crawford and M. Young

I would be getting McCutchen and others. Here is my roster

C - Mauer, Soto
1B - Morneau, Votto
2nd - Castilo
SS - Rollins, Theriot
3B - Reynolds, Young
OF - Beltran, Crawford, Either, Adam Jones, BJ Upton, Maggs, Fernando Martinez

SP - Carp, Webb, Dempster, Hamels, Bedard, Garland, Maine, Hochevar,

Am I giving up too much? I like that I shore up 2B and get a nice young OF in McCutchen but..

...and as always WHIR
RP - Valverde, Rodney

[Johnny Tuttle]

I take it, but it's really close, and I'm only 51% in favor of it.

Zobrist trumps Crawford for me, and that's not thick ice I'm on.

McCutcheon, even as only legs, is someone I take over Ethier myself, but I'm notoriously down on Ethier.

The others are a wash, but I like having the OF here and Victorino seems like he'll age well. Young is misnomer.

If you are cool with your post trade OF, then it's a yes. You will need a thumper in your OF if Upton craps out, but that's likely true either way.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=401233

[Tenacious D-Store]

There's no guarantee Zobrist can repeat, at least you know what you'll get from Young, and you are upgrading 2 OF's by a pretty large margin. No brainer for me. This guy clearly has a stiffy for Zobrist and you're ripping him off. It will be a lesson learned for him, I'd accept without hesitation.

EDIT: Wait the guy with the stiffy is YOU!!! lol

Don't do this trade man, it really isn't even close.