Studs: 6. I can keep: 3. Need help.

[Fantasy GM]

I've been away for awhile, but now I'm back in the fantasy baseball mood. In a few days, I need to select my three keepers in my highly competitive league. It is points H2H:
-For hitters, the scoring rewards power a little more than speed in terms of overall points. OBP is a plus too.
-Starting pitchers are vital. If they pitch very well, they'll score a lot of points and you'll be in a good position to win. If they don't pitch well, you'll certainly feel the effects.
-Hitters have 6-7 days to accumulate their points. SP's only have 1, sometimes 2 outings to score each week.
-Lineups feature 9 hitters (C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, 3 OF, UTL) and 9 pitchers (5 SP, 3 RP, 1 P)

Keeping this in mind, which three players do I keep?
- 1B Miguel Cabrera - very consistent, but didn't have the huge HR/RBI numbers in 2009.
- 1B Ryan Howard - enormous power and one of the top-scoring hitters, but can be streaky.
- OF Matt Kemp - five-tool production and consistent, but Howard and Cabrera both outscored him.
- SP Dan Haren - Sensational first half, rough second half.
- SP CC Sabathia - Rough first half, sensational second half.
- SP Adam Wainwright - A top-10 SP, but is he really better than Haren or CC?

[posty]

I would go Howard, Kemp and Sabathia...

[waltb87]

Id go with Ryan Howard, Miguel Cabrera, and CC....im pretty sure the consensus will be for Howard and CC, kind of up in the air for the third spot

[hstlives]

If you can only keep three, then I would start looking for trades. Get something out of those guys. I would keep Howard, Miggy, and Kemp. But if you can move one of those guys then I would go with CC.

[raiders_umpire]

Mcab
Howard
Kemp

[footballisbetter.com]

Mcab
Howard
Kemp

I agree. Your 3 hitters seem to be the most valuable to me.

[Johnny Tuttle]

Cabrera, Howard, CC.

If Hanley does well in your format, I should think you're trying that route, too, no? Pujols, too.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=401233

[Tenacious D-Store]

Mcab
Howard
Kemp

Howard at 1st, Miggy at Utility and 90 Homers right there. Stick with offense, there will be lots of pitching available in the draft

[briane]

Cabrera, Kemp, Haren.

I have a feeling about the sober Miggy this year (27 years old in April) and Haren has the best numbers of the bunch (averaged over a season).

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=401238

[HOOTIE]

Mcab
Howard
Kemp