Trade for Butler, Anderson or Jimenez

[Chadgo5]

Roto 6x6 (IP and OBP added) - 11 teams - $260 auction - C / 1B / 2B / SS / 3B / 4OF / 2UT / 5SP / 3RP - 6 keepers

Going into the auction really cheap this year (more because I had a weak team and have some bargains, rather than choice). I'm rebuilding. We keep 6. Here are my five so far:

C - Matt Wieters - $5
2B - Aaron Hill - $5
OF - Nelson Cruz - $5
OF - Nick Markakis - $13
RP - Jonathan Broxton - $5

I have three trades on the table to fill my last keeper spot... Billy Butler, Ubaldo Jimenez or Brett Anderson. All are $5 players. I would on;y give a farm team draft pick up in return.

WIth this deal, I would throw David Wright $39 and Johan Santana $27 back into the pool (both too high $$ IMO). But I'd have $222 left to get them back... and enough money to build a solid team.

Which of Butler, Anderson or Jimenez would you choose?

[BillyHallDisciple]

I'm a big Ubaldo fan and own him in both leagues I'm in, but I always prefer hitters over pitchers so I'd go with Butler first, then Ubaldo second. Anderson 3rd.

[HOOTIE]

I like all 3, but close

Anderson
Jimenez
Butler

[BoBtheMule]

Anderson
Butler
Jimenez

It's hard to go wrong w/ any of them though.

[raiders_umpire]

I like all three as well

Jimenez
Butler
Anderson

[Johnny Tuttle]

I like Ubaldo there.

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=401233

[Tenacious D-Store]

Anderson will be great, but probably not this season. Gotta go with Baldy, Butler then Anderson.

[briane]

Butler
Anderson
Ubaldo

Offense first, and I am especially scared of Rockie pitchers going a few seasons.

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=401238

[BigLebowski]

I like all three as well

Jimenez
Butler
Anderson

This is how I'd rank them.

[Chadgo5]

Jimenez offer was pulled. I'm going with Anderson...Thanks for the help!!