Need help with 4 keepers

[hanny2042]

I have to keep 4 guys in my Head to Head, 5x5 (standard) keeper league. My options are below (I listed some that are probably obviously down on the list, but figured I'd throw anyone even garnering a possibility):

Joe Mauer C MIN
Ryan Zimmerman 3B WAS
Ben Zobrist 2B TB
Dustin Pedroia 2B BOS
Ichiro Suzuki OF SEA
Matt Holliday OF STL
Jay Bruce OF CIN
Dan Haren SP ARI
Justin Verlander SP DET
Brandon Webb SP ARI
Jonathan Papelbon RP BOS
Brian Fuentes RP LAA

Thanks for any recommendations!

[reider3]

[quote="hanny2042"]I have to keep 4 guys in my Head to Head, 5x5 (standard) keeper league. My options are below (I listed some that are probably obviously down on the list, but figured I'd throw anyone even garnering a possibility):

Joe Mauer C MIN
Ryan Zimmerman 3B WAS
Ben Zobrist 2B TB
Dustin Pedroia 2B BOS
Ichiro Suzuki OF SEA
Matt Holliday OF STL
Jay Bruce OF CIN
Dan Haren SP ARI
Justin Verlander SP DET
Brandon Webb SP ARI
Jonathan Papelbon RP BOS
Brian Fuentes RP LAA

Thanks for any recommendations![/quote]

[bigken117]

Mauer
Zimm
Pedroia
Holliday


help w mine?

[BALCO All-Stars]

Mauer
Zimm
Pedroia
Holliday


help w mine?

+1

[sparkyspark]

Mauer
Zimm
Pedroia
Holliday


help w mine?

+3

I agree
Take a look at mine if you have a sec(PICK 2)

[hanny2042]

Wow, so nobody would keep any pitchers? My only other keeper leagues are set up to keep many more players (so picking players is easier) or dynasty, so I may over-value keeping at least one pitcher...

[sman]

I'd also go with Mauer, Zimmerman, Pedroia, and Holliday.

If you feel you have to keep a pitcher, I'd go with Haren over the others. It's just usually not worth losing a positional spot for a pitcher since the positional guys go everyday.

Please help with mine: viewtopic.php?t=401159

[HOOTIE]

Pedroia is overrated. Verlander or Haren easily for me.