First Time Poster... Need to keep five!

[Bully's Ears]

Quite the myriad of responses... I appreciate all of your thoughts!

Oddly enough, the five I had long been planning to keep (Pujols, Crawford, VMART, Votto, Bay) wasn't tossed oout there until the eighth response!

Lots of love for Beckham here, which I totally understand. To have a middle infielder for years to come would be beyond sweet. My thought is that he's going around the mid-eighties ADP-wise, and is ranked (bizarrely) somewhere in the mid 130's in the Yahoo O-Ranking. My first two picks (including the 60 keepers in our league) are #70 and #75. Would I be foolish to keep Bay and hope those first nine pass on GBeck?

[HOOTIE]

Albert Pujols
Carl Crawford
Gordon Beckham
Andrew McCutchen
Joey Votto

Got to take AM over Vmart, and the demands of catching.

[HOOTIE]

Quite the myriad of responses... I appreciate all of your thoughts!

Oddly enough, the five I had long been planning to keep (Pujols, Crawford, VMART, Votto, Bay) wasn't tossed oout there until the eighth response!

Lots of love for Beckham here, which I totally understand. To have a middle infielder for years to come would be beyond sweet. My thought is that he's going around the mid-eighties ADP-wise, and is ranked (bizarrely) somewhere in the mid 130's in the Yahoo O-Ranking. My first two picks (including the 60 keepers in our league) are #70 and #75. Would I be foolish to keep Bay and hope those first nine pass on GBeck?

McCutchen is 23, Bay 32, Vmart 31.

AM is projected already over VMart, and only $2 behind Bay. Beckham at 24, is only $1 behind VMart. At years end, you will kick yourself for keeping Bay/VMart over Beckham and AM.

[MaudDib]

Quite the myriad of responses... I appreciate all of your thoughts!

Oddly enough, the five I had long been planning to keep (Pujols, Crawford, VMART, Votto, Bay) wasn't tossed oout there until the eighth response!

Lots of love for Beckham here, which I totally understand. To have a middle infielder for years to come would be beyond sweet. My thought is that he's going around the mid-eighties ADP-wise, and is ranked (bizarrely) somewhere in the mid 130's in the Yahoo O-Ranking. My first two picks (including the 60 keepers in our league) are #70 and #75. Would I be foolish to keep Bay and hope those first nine pass on GBeck?

McCutchen is 23, Bay 32, Vmart 31.

AM is projected already over VMart, and only $2 behind Bay. Beckham at 24, is only $1 behind VMart. At years end, you will kick yourself for keeping Bay/VMart over Beckham and AM.

I would agree with this. I was flipping back and forth between VMart and AM. I would take AM easily over Bay.