My league has minor league keepers - you get one player and you have the rights to keep him his entire career if you want. If you take a guy and he is a bust, you can re-enter the minor league draft each offseason and pick a new player. Obviously, once you land a stud, you don't participate in the Minor League Draft anymore (each team can only have one keeper at any given time). For the record, my current keeper is Colby Rasmus, and although I think he will be a solid player, I am really looking to strike gold here.
One catch: The player can't have any MLB experience.
Fantasy Points H2H league, pretty standard scoring.
Now to the question. Looks like I will have the 3rd pick, and I am assuming that Heyward and Strasburg will come off before me.
Who do I go for?
Mike Stanton (might be a year away, but I can stand to wait if he truly is going to be a star) Pedro Alvarez Desmond Jennings Justin Smoak Any other suggestions?
Let me also add that I have Miguel Cabrera and Matt Kemp as my MLB keepers.
It is a tricky situation, because if I don't take a player like Stanton, and he makes a brief appearance at the end of the year, I won't be able to draft him next year. I screwed myself Upton's rookie year thinking he would stay down all season. I am wary of D. Jennings because these "toolsy" outfielders always seem to be slow out of the gates. See Rasmus, Maybin, et al. McCutchen is an exception I can think of. I really want a Ryan Braun type power bat, which is why I am looking at Alvarez, Stanton, maybe Montero, very hard.
That said, it is likely that I will be one of only two people participating in the Minor League Draft next year - so I could try to pick someone a little closer to a 2010 roster spot than Stanton and hope Stanton will be available next year.
Yeah, but he can't keep Rasmus as a minor, so there is really no point in keeping him as one of his few MLB guys. He's looking for a superstar, so I would look to high risk guys, even if they have a less than 50% chance of breaking out. I don't like Stanton's K rate in the high minors. Guys with those kind of k/bb ratios don't usually explode onto the major league scene. I'd prefer Logan Morrison or even a high ceiling SP like Martin Perez, who is perhaps the best lefty prospect in all of MiLB.
In my fridge: Founders Kentucky Breakfast Stout (KBS), Central Waters Peruvian Morning, Bell's Batch 10,000, Dale's Pale Ale, Capital Brewery Amber, New Glarus Moon Man, and Guinness.
Major League Manager
Joined: 7 May 2004
Home Cafe: Baseball
Location: Finally back home. A sweet 15 mi from Miller Park.