Would you trade Pujols for Miggy Cabrera and David Wright?

[Tenacious D-Store]

I like the deal, but have to say that MCab does not drive in a ton of runs in this Tigers lineup. He just won't. There isn't enough around him. Pujols will have 35 RBI's on him probably. Pujols average will be slightly higher, will hit about the same number of homeruns, and probably steal a few more bases. But assuming Wright is replacing someone bad at 3B, then this is a good deal. Not an unbelievable deal, but it will help you.

That Tiger line up makes me cry. Clete Thomas, Raburn and Mags in the OF, Rookie Scott Sizemore, Adam Everett, Inge and Miggy (who is awesome) in the infield. Liard stinks offensively at catcher and Avila stinks defensively at catcher. There is a reason I opted not to compare RBI production. I'd still probably do the deal.

[oddmanout7]

I would do that deal. 2 top 25 guys for the #1 overall pick seems about right. And I expect DWright to bounceback, and Miggy has been trying to lay off the booze.