Crawford round 3 Werth round 8 Matt LaPorta round 21 Colby Rasmus round 22 Chris Coghlan round 23
Even though your league counts SLG, Crawford at 3rd should at least break even. Werth at 8 is a steal IMO. The other three guys could become potential superstars, and at those prices are good investments.
Josh Johnson is also worth some consideration too. At round 11, he would be a mega steal, but his huge increase in IP along with his injury history is too much of a red flag for me.
So it seems Crawford, Werth, and Coghlan are the only ones every one agrees on. I like Johnson in the 11th. I think this could be a breakout year for him. I'm still not sure about #5. I've gotten Alcides Escobar, LaPorta, and Rasmus all as suggestion. I'm leaning toward Escobar especially because of his position. I'm not sold on Rasmus yet. LaPorta I might regret not keeping, but he has yet to prove himself in the bigs(although Coghlan has only shown half a season, but I do think he is for real). Thanks for the suggestion keep them coming and I'll keep putting out my advice to everyone.