Dyntasty Deal (Heyward Kemp involved) Experts needed

[tnohren]

Dynasty League.. h2h keep 16 after each year....

Side A receives Heyward and BJ Upton
Side B receives Kemp and Hellickson

please vote and give your insight thanks!!!

[MaudDib]

Man this is tough. I like Heyward and Upton a lot BUT Kemp is the best player in the deal. If I was on either side of the deal, I would have a hard time pulling the trigger. I think I would prefer the Kemp deal only because he is the best player. As much as I like Upton, he has burned me and many owners in the past and he could do that again and Heyward is far from a sure thing. I would hate to be the guy that traded Braun for BJ Upton and Alex Gordon a few years ago.

[jtrain19]

if you have Kemp --- hold on to him. The deal looks good but Kemp is a high first rounder and a top 2 OF. If kemp was a 29 I could see a better case for it.. but he is only 25!!!






viewtopic.php?t=400711

[dave knight]

Heyward and BJ Upton. The difference between Heyward/Hellickson is much bigger than Kemp/Upton.

[HOOTIE]

Side B. Kemp is already great. A could turn out better, but why trade the sure thing for a maybe sure thing?

I know Heyward is a can't miss, but so were Delmon Young and Mark Prior.

[ensanimal]

Kemp side. Heyward can still only dream of being like Kemp. Hellickson is no slouch of a prospect either.

[dave knight]

Side B. Kemp is already great. A could turn out better, but why trade the sure thing for a maybe sure thing?

I know Heyward is a can't miss, but so were Delmon Young and Mark Prior.

Unlike Delmon, Heyward has some idea of the strike zone.