Keeper trade (WHIR)

[crod8712]

H2H, Keeper (Keep 15), 5x5

Should I deal CC Sabathia and Ichiro for Crawford and Michael Young? Not sure if I should saacrifice the pitcher for the SB's and a 3b (not much left). I do get a bit younger...

Catcher: Joe Mauer C
First Baseman: Mark Teixeira 1B
Second Baseman: Brandon Phillips 2B
Third Baseman:
Short Stop: Hanley Ramirez SS
Out Field: Curtis Granderson OF
Out Field: Cameron Maybin OF
Out Field: Ichiro Suzuki OF
Utility: Miguel Cabrera 1B
Utility: Derrek Lee 1B

Starting Pitchers:
1. C.C. Sabathia
2. Josh Johnson
3. Cliff Lee
4. Felix Hernanadez
5. Matt Cain
6. Madison Bumgarner

[birdbrains]

no stay with the ACE and the 2010 batting average leader

can you look at mine
thanks
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=400600

[zepfan]

Nice pitching staff.

Not a bad deal but I'm not too big on Young really. If you could try to sub out CC and replace him with Lee instead that would be better IMO but if you're just looking to fill in the holes on your team, this trade is not bad.

[rotoquest]

No way. Stay put with the bases you already have.

[dave knight]

I'd like it better with Cliff Lee, but overall this is a solid deal for you.

[HollywoodHartman]

I have to agree with the masses here, as the upgrade from Ichiro to Crawford isn't nearly as big as the downgrade to Young.

viewtopic.php?t=400697 Here's mine.

[dmendro]

Yes do this. Here's why. Michael Young plays a mean first half every year. Ride him and then trade him at the end of may beginning of June. You will get more bang for your buck.

[redsoxsucker]

Young is a throwaway in this deal..it's basically CC and Ichiro for Crawford, which is far from even...

Please help
viewtopic.php?t=400507