Keeper Conundrum

[Fixations]

12 Team Head-to-Head

Pujols and ARod are two of my keepers

what situation looks better

1) Pujols, ARod, Reyes, CC
2) Pujols, ARod, Lincecum, CC
3) Pujols, ARod, Lincecum, Justin Upton
4) Pujols, ARod, Reyes, Justin Upton

[oldmanbean]

12 Team Head-to-Head

Pujols and ARod are two of my keepers

what situation looks better

1) Pujols, ARod, Reyes, CC
2) Pujols, ARod, Lincecum, CC
3) Pujols, ARod, Lincecum, Justin Upton
4) Pujols, ARod, Reyes, Justin Upton

I like number 3 the best, not too much faith in Sabathia, Linc is one of the tops, and Reyes is too iffy.

[HOOTIE]

3

[jake_twothousandfive]

Definitely #3.

[Fixations]

I agree with you guys.

Here is a little twist to my league. We get to protect 3 right away. Then every time a player from last year's team gets drafted - you get to protect back another player.

So - Keeping Pujols and ARod is a no brainer. I have to decide who my other protection going into the draft is. Should I keep Lincecum or Reyes. This is what I have thought so far would happen come draft day.


KEEPERS
Pujols
ARod
Linceccum
DRAFTED - PROTECTED
Reyes - J. Upton
CC - Cano
Beckett - Wieters
Beckham - A. Jones
Burnett - Webb or Pence

or

KEEPERS
Pujols
ARod
Reyes
DRAFTED - PROTECTED
Lincecum - CC
Upton - Wieters
Cano - Beckham
Beckett - Burnett
A. Jones - Webb or Pence

Any thoughts?

[zebulon]

Seems kind of wierd, but I think you gotta protect Lincecum.