help me with my keepers WHIR

[fierro33]

i can keep only 5

justin upton
bj upton
joe mauer
ryan zimmerman
dustin pedroia
evan longoria
josh beckett

[theschwartz]

i can keep only 5

justin upton
bj upton
joe mauer
ryan zimmerman
dustin pedroia
evan longoria
josh beckett

[MaudDib]

i can keep only 5

justin upton
bj upton
joe mauer
ryan zimmerman
dustin pedroia
evan longoria
josh beckett

[footballisbetter.com]

i can keep only 5

justin upton
bj upton
joe mauer
ryan zimmerman
dustin pedroia
evan longoria
josh beckett

+1

[fezzik]

i can keep only 5

justin upton
bj upton
joe mauer
ryan zimmerman
dustin pedroia
evan longoria
josh beckett

I think BJ Upton has the potential to bounce back, but I would take Zimmerman over him as he's more of a sure thing...even though he will be your 2nd 3B. I assume you can start him at UT or perhaps CI if you are in a deeper league.

[HOOTIE]

i can keep only 5

justin upton
bj upton
joe mauer
ryan zimmerman
dustin pedroia
evan longoria
josh beckett

[burntfaceman]

I'd take
justin upton
joe mauer
ryan zimmerman
dustin pedroia
evan longoria

help me too please? viewtopic.php?t=400524

[HOOTIE]

i can keep only 5

justin upton
bj upton
joe mauer
ryan zimmerman
dustin pedroia
evan longoria
josh beckett

Why BJ or Pedroia over Zimm?

[MaudDib]

i can keep only 5

justin upton
bj upton
joe mauer
ryan zimmerman
dustin pedroia
evan longoria
josh beckett

Why BJ or Pedroia over Zimm?

I think BJ will have a better season than last year. The HR should go up along with the BA which will cause everything else to go up as well. If that is the case then Zimmerman and Upton will be valued very similarly. Zimmerman would get you more HR but Upton more SB. Of course he is taking a risk with Upton but I think it will pay off. I have no problem with him taking Zimmerman over Upton but I hate filling my Util spot so early. It limits your ability to draft a guy that might have fallen to far in the draft then he should because you wouldn't have a spot to play him.