Keeper TRADE - Pujols/Rollins or Fielder/Hanley WHIR!

[Cypher74]

Hey guys,

Yahoo points league. Right now my three keepers are Pujols, Rollins and either Carpenter, Broxton or Lester. I have a chance to swap Pujols to the league champ who has too many keepers. Would you deal Pujols (and consequently drop Rollins) for Hanley and Fielder?

Points league where EVERYTHING counts - 2b, 3b, bb, k, errors, etc. Last year in our scoring system, Pujols outscored Fielder 685-549 - a significant difference. Hanley and Rollins were similar in points, though Hanley did it in almost 200 less AB's due to injury.

Would you do this deal???

Will HELP in reutrn - Leave a link!

[SLBarnes]

I would do this for sure. You give up arguably the best player in baseball for arguabley the second best...plus with Hanley you get SB. While you lose a little power you gain it back and then some with Fielder.
Pujols for Hanley and Salad? I'd say jump all over it.

[HOOTIE]

Yes. Keep Hanley/Fielder/Rollins or Lester. No way on Broxton.

[Hawkeye1]

I'd do it. Fielder will be productive. I also like Hanley over Rollins. Do you have to give up draft picks to keep players? If so, I'd hang on to Lester as your 3rd keeper.

[RenT]

Thanks for the help on mine. Essentially it's Pujols/Rollins for Fielder/Hanley since you'll be dropping Rollins here. I'd do the deal because I'm a huge Hanley fan and Fielder is an elite 1B too. Lester is also your 3rd keeper here. Good trade.

[Darth Danielus]

Fielder/ramirez>>>pujols/rollins. Do it for sure...




Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=400451

[dave knight]

Fielder/Hanley looks better to me than Pujols/Rollins.

[theschwartz]

Definitely a good trade, you are losing Pujols' average by swapping him with Fielder but what you are gaining by getting Hanley greatly outweighs that. You are getting two first round picks for a first and second/third.
viewtopic.php?t=400499

[fezzik]

Definitely Fielder/Hanley for me...I would also keep Rollins over any of your pitchers if that is an option, though I know some formats require you to keep at least one pitcher.