AGon and Wright for Hanley?(WHIR)

[TheTrickster]

I agree with just about everything said already. My first thought was that he was trying to buy low on Wright and it wasn't worth giving up both him and Agon especially since you have Rollins already. Any chance he would add Longoria instead of Mcab or Fielder if you put in Rollins?

[kidsilk]

Change in the action here. He said he would take one of AGon or Wright and JRoll for Hanley. Should I do it and if so who should I give up? AGon or Wright? I leaning towards Wright and Rollins for Hanley. Or should I just keep what I have? Thanks and leave a link!

[The Artful Dodger]

I would try A-Gon and Rollins for Hanley first.

[teeznutz]

Too much to give on Hanley. I too have A Gonzo and Wright and will never consider both for Hanley.

Please help:

viewtopic.php?t=400502

[Montana168]

hey man...thanks for the help with mine.

first off, that other team's offense is stacked. i mean downright ridiculous. with that being said, he needs pitching. he does hav a somewhat underrated 1-2 punch with webb/peavy but who knows how well both with bounce back. you do hav the extra 3b with arod and wright that you can afford to deal one, but you dont have the 1b to do it. id try and counter with something like agon/wright/one of ur stud pitchers for hanley/one of his stud 1b. not sure if it'll work but he will hav an excess amount of 1b since there is no way mcab is 3b eligible. try that and it should work. if not, i still would do the deal. wright's power is risky and everyone is just assuming it will return, but that probably shouldnt be the case. 1b is very deep this yr and im sure you can go get a guy like kendry or votto for a fair amount, u have solid pitching depth that you can deal for 1. hanley/kendry > agon/wright IMO.

[kidsilk]

He did say he was also interested in Felix.

Should I offer AGon/Wright/Felix/JRoll for Hanley/MCab/pitcher? Or is that too much to give up?

[NOTLOWNF]

I wouldn't do it. If Wright gets his power back then he is a top 5 guy again and not that far from Hanley's #'s and he plays at a thin position. I would only do it if he through in a better second player or you gave him someone less than Gonzalez.

Just to confuse things a little.... It doesn't make your team better this YEAR but If you are thinking of the future then It would make more sense. I guess it depends on what is more important... this year or the future.

[BALCO All-Stars]

CAVEAT: I only play in 5x5 leagues...

1. A-Gon and Rollins for Hanley - book it. Give me some Hanley
2. Wright/A-Gon for Hanley - pass. You already have Rollins at SS and Drew at MI...doing this trade makes Drew go to the bench (or UTIL where he's not an ideal choice but he's more the solid at MI). Plus, who would you start at 1B and CI?

Thanks for the help with mine.

[Burke]

Thanks for helping with mine!

I think you should forget trying to figure out how to land Hanley .
You drafted a very strong,balanced team and I think you should start the season
with those guys. I always hate to make a big trade between the draft aand the start
of the season if I was happy with the draft. There's always time to offer a blockbuster
trade once the season starts.

[birdbrains]

i wouldnt...wright with bay and healty Met supporty cast should have a big yr...