Roy Halladay?

[Johnny Tuttle]

I give Carlos Santana and Jake Peavy for Roy Halladay?

It's a H2H keeper and I'm trying to win now. I already have Victor Martinez, and I doubt that I could carry 2 catchers on a 26 man roster, esp. so as I have enough hitters that I can't keep Matt LaPorta already.

Still, is this enough of an upgrade to get rid of a stud catching prospect?

[btb2007]

Do it. Peavy is risky and Halladay moving to the NL is going to be nasty.

[Elsy]

That is great value for you. Doc will win the NL CY Young this year....sorry Timmy no 3 in a row.

[Johnny Tuttle]

With your signature, should I be skeptical?

[Elsy]

I'm a Jays fan first and foremost. Am I glad that Doc is gone to Philly...FUCKING HELL NO!!!! Is he still the best pitcher in the game HELL YES!!!! I may actually start following the Phillies just b/c Doc is there.

But seriously, he is a workhorse the only thing that may hinder is his stats is being pulled late in games and not getting a CG because Manuel wants to PH for him. His ERA, K's will both improve, it is hard to improve on like a average 18 game win season but I see at least 20 for him this year easy. He is going be dominate in the NL

[Johnny Tuttle]

Thank you. I'm a Jays fan, too. I get what you're saying, for sure.

[Yankeefan!4]

DO IT!!!

[Seanyfever]

I am still miffed I didnt get Halladay when he was dangled in my own off season. I'd do this.