Manny trade

[jtrain19]

Team A gets: Manny and Ubaldo

Team B gets: Jay Bruce, Edwin Jackson and Ian Stewart

which team wins??

Is it a fair deal??

[tribefan08]

i defly like trade B better....

but all in all its a fair deal....

i just think manny is on his downslide, obviosuly, and ubaldo isn't that good to outweigh bruce and stewart, but they're both HUGE question marks in 2010, huge upside, but who knows...

I GO "B".

[kidsilk]

I like A better. I still think Manny has some good years ahead of him and Ubaldo is going to be a stud this year. Bruce and Stewart are too unproven for my tastes. But it is a fair trade overall.

please help

viewtopic.php?t=399944