Keeper Question- Bret Anderson or Coghlan as rookie keeper

[grandpa]

Which one? If I go with Coghlan, I will draft all arms. If I go with Anderson, I will go all SP but need to grab and OF- Thoughts and WHIR. Head to Head total points league- no categories. In my league, Coghlan would have finished as the 18th OF tied with Ichiro with 600 ABs- he finished as the 31st OF with 500 ABs last year. Bret Anderson was the 58th ranked SP last year in my league. Tough call- probably could re-draft both, but which one goes first?

c- VMart
1b- Berkman
2b- Beckham
SS- Alcides Escobar
3b- Longoria
OF- Holliday
OF- Sizemore
OF- Adam Jones
U- Coghlan or empty

SP- W. Davis

[GreenMtn!]

I would go with Anderson over Coghlan. They are almost identical in MDP lists I've seen, but I think Anderson will be going first in a lot of leagues. You already have 3 good outfielders, so I'd go with the pitcher.

[Grounded Polo]

Brett Anderson by a mile to me.

[jonboy418]

You're going to get Anderson 99.9% of the responses here. I would personally keep him over Davis.

Coghlan will get you god average, but after than, his stats are pedestrian. Anderson has the potential to be a great pitcher.