houstonherdfan wrote:Well, I asked both Dan and Wacoug for reasons not to suspect them of being mafia, and all I got were reasons to suspect me.
Since I was the one who saved GF14 last night, that takes me out and still haven't heard why to not suspect either of them. Only more accusations.
Still going to wait cause we need to be sure of our vote. GF14 you are right they will kill me tonight and I am not allowed to save myself, I already asked.
If we pick correctly at least you all will have a shot at taking the last mafioso out with 3 against 1.
OK HFF, after reading a lot of your posts and doing some thinking, I believe you are the doctor and since you gave yourself up, it's a very good chance GF is also a townie (just as you claim). I have had a feeling you were a townie the whole time, and only really voted for you early on in day 1 because you weren't saying much and I wanted to stir the pot.
I can do nothing more to really prove my innocence than state that I've been actively posting and that has made me at least a tertiary target of suspicion as I talk things through my head out loud and make momentary votes to get people's goats. I have only been on one of the two ouster-votes (Shizz) and I really did believe he was mafia (along with 1-3 other townies) because of his crazy weird actions.
GiantsFan14 wrote:i agree with this completely. i just went back and looked at day 1 (which i should have done as soon as teddy was killed), and teddy was definitely suspicious of dan throughout a lot of that thread. i can easily see him being the guy that teddy targetted that night.
I have been suspicious of Dan on a gut level feeling this whole time, but actually believe urban is a much bigger threat as a likely mafioso. Dan could likely be his partner, or Aussie (who I thought was the doc) could be as well, but I think that Urban is a more likely silent partner (to Dan) for that criminal duo than Aussie at this point. Urban is more the silent mafia type (read my post about how he disappeared for 5 pages of day 1 and all of day 2 until posting the kill vote on Shizz) than Aussie, who's likely just on his usual different time schedule and is bored cause he's prolly a regular townie on a "sinking ship".
urbanbreez wrote:It looks like HHF has talked his way off my list for now. Although, its worth noting that there is no way to verify his claim. If there is another "real" doc out there, he may not want to dispute HHF's claim since that makes him a clear mafia target.
Here is my list:
I think this helps to prove my suspicions of urban, as he is casting the most doubt on probably the least suspicious guy, then tucks the quite-suspicious Dan in between me and the two who are claiming to be doctor and regular townie. HFF can be at the bottom of his (published) list, cause he's a goner tonight, meaning we HAVE to get 4 votes for a mafia.
houstonherdfan wrote:If we get through the day with a 3 - 1 advantage. I would look at either wacoug or Urban as the other mafia.
Wacoug due to other susipicions plus that edit. what did he put out there he didn't want us to see.
Urban for that accuasation that I wasn't the doc.
Anyone would see that there is really only 1 more day at most so me as the doc decided to give out my info and take my death for the overall good of the town. If I was BS'en it the real doc would have seen the advatage to the town to reveal himself and would have.
If you honestly think my post editing mistake from my Apple POS phone is suspicious/grounds for lynching, then I'm not going to be able to change your mind, but that's pretty weak at best. I think you are right on about it likely being Dan and Urban (if you take me out of the equation). Though I don't completely agree about your reasoning on the doc, I think that the option you've presented is, in fact, the most likely one. Urban accusing you of not being the doc just seems like a last-ditch effort to try (again) to divert attention from my postings about how he disappeared for like 2 days (after not being that active anyway) and then quietly nailed a guy on the verge of lynching before disappearing until 10-15 posts into Day 3...