Heyward for Ackley, Chapman & Escobar

[Members Only Jackets]

Hi

it involves minors so I decided to post here.

H2H Dynasty

I give: Heyward

I get: Ackley and A Chapman

Like it?

thanks a lot (leave a link WHIR)

[Whalewang]

I like it a lot...for the other team.

[Members Only Jackets]

I like it a lot...for the other team.

yeah...

what if I ask him to throw in Escobar (ss for brewers)

[cardinal1975]

I likely would still lean with the Heyward side of the trade. It would help however if you listed how many teams in your league, how many keepers, your roster, etc, to get a more accurate assessment of the deal.

[ensanimal]

I'd rather Heyward by a fair margin.

[MaudDib]

Unless you are getting Strasburg then don't trade Heyward. There are few prospects who have the upside that Heyward projects.

[Members Only Jackets]

thanks all

I went with this deal after talking w the other guy.

I gave: K Drabek

I get: D Ackley and Scott Sizemore

thoughts?

[Johnny Tuttle]

I quite like that for you. Sizemore could have his uses in 2010 as he settles in, and Ackley is certainly a nice score. Drabek seems like a good commodity, but he's still a young SP in the AL East for a team pressured to rush him to justify trading Halladay. And the Jays defense is going south in a hurry.

Asset wise and value wise, this was a coup.

[Members Only Jackets]

I quite like that for you. Sizemore could have his uses in 2010 as he settles in, and Ackley is certainly a nice score. Drabek seems like a good commodity, but he's still a young SP in the AL East for a team pressured to rush him to justify trading Halladay. And the Jays defense is going south in a hurry.

Asset wise and value wise, this was a coup.

yeah, thanks Johnny...especially if Ackley can handle 2b. We'll see.